I have seen enough of Forbath to know he is not better than Sloman. In fact, I'd argue Sloman was better, particularly factoring his touchbacks/kick returns compared to Forbath.
Time to try MacGinnis.
Time to try MacGinnis.
Rams have a serious kicker problem
- Thread starter madrid311
- Start date
-
To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
sjm1582002
Wanted everywhere but welcome nowhere
Whatever happened to the mouthful, Lirim Hajrullahu?
He damn sure had a strong leg for kickoffs.
He damn sure had a strong leg for kickoffs.
We should have tried to see what the Giants would have wanted for Graham Gano
I'd promote MacGinnis. Try to get Hajrullahu on the PS.
Another option would be to go after Rohrwasser on the Patriots PS. He had solid college numbers and decent kickoff length, but he had a rough start in Pats camp. It sounds like he's been improving throughout the season. There's a chance it forces the Pats to activate him to their active roster. I'd still consider that a small win.
Another option would be to go after Rohrwasser on the Patriots PS. He had solid college numbers and decent kickoff length, but he had a rough start in Pats camp. It sounds like he's been improving throughout the season. There's a chance it forces the Pats to activate him to their active roster. I'd still consider that a small win.
You do realize he is holder as well. Too many variables to change IMO.
Maybe we should have stashed Lucy and Charlie Brown on the PS? Lucy is an underated holder.
I still have his TOPPs card. Sweet beard he was rocking, if I remember correctly.
You would think so. It's not like teams all over the league are stashing good kickers on their practice squad. Are they? Frustrating situation.
Let's just see what MacGinnis can do and cut Forbath. I'm sorry, but he's not the answer, and he's now hurt.
And before you call me a hypocrite for wanting Forbath gone and not Sloman at first, I'll remind you that Sloman's a rookie. Forbath was known to have his issues on kickoffs and beyond the 50. What wasn't known was how he would end up playing.
And before you call me a hypocrite for wanting Forbath gone and not Sloman at first, I'll remind you that Sloman's a rookie. Forbath was known to have his issues on kickoffs and beyond the 50. What wasn't known was how he would end up playing.
McVay is receiving his real-time lesson on special teams this season. He's a quick study though so hopefully he realizes he can't trust Bonamego and will take his input with a fucking grain of salt in this search.
If I were in McVay's shoes I would be on the horn with Andy Reid asking for permission to hire Andy Hill away from the Chiefs right now. It's a job upgrade and Reid may allow it. And for the record I know nothing about Andy Hill other than the fact that Dave Toub is the best ST coach in the league in my opinion and Hill's his understudy.
But either way Bonamego would be fired this week. I dislike almost every single thing they have done under his direction. Poor hire, ok fix it and move forward. If I had to dip down into the college ranks to replace him so be it.
If I were in McVay's shoes I would be on the horn with Andy Reid asking for permission to hire Andy Hill away from the Chiefs right now. It's a job upgrade and Reid may allow it. And for the record I know nothing about Andy Hill other than the fact that Dave Toub is the best ST coach in the league in my opinion and Hill's his understudy.
But either way Bonamego would be fired this week. I dislike almost every single thing they have done under his direction. Poor hire, ok fix it and move forward. If I had to dip down into the college ranks to replace him so be it.
ramsince62
Hall of Fame
simonblaze
Pro Bowler
I knew something smelled bad with ST when they had Cooper Kupp returning punts...
I’d send Forbath packing, elevate Mcginnis, and sign Lirim to the PS. We do have an extra day.
I don't see a problem with bringing in a guy with a power leg from soccer or rugby and putting him on the PS while you coach him up. Unfortunately there's that small detail about who's doing the coaching lol. But I think if you invited a handful of those types and have them do kickoffs on a tee then sign the one who kicks the furthest consistently what do you have to lose? We already miss easy field goals. Might find a diamond in the rough never know.