How Did You Feel About The Split HB Formation???

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

RamWoodie

Legend
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
6,940
ROD Credits
36,820
The Ram offense featured the split HB formation against the Cards and early in the game it worked pretty well. However the seemed to abandon it later in the 2nd quarter. I liked the formation and after a few passes to KW and Corum The Cards seemed to get a handle on it.

I think with more development, this is a good formation (typically called "pro set offense") they can do a bit more from it, though I'm not sure where McVay will go with it. I think they only had a few plays with it but in the "Pre-game thread" a few of us had talked about splitting the backs in the backfield and low and behold, we saw it .

How did you feel about the formation...should they continue to work from it or not???

A typical pro set formation:

pro_set.webp
 
It's cool if Sean can get creative out of this formation. From what I saw it seemed rather pedestrian, but somewhat effective in getting underneath routes open.

We'll see, I want to see them run out of this formation and mix it up a little. But we'll see. The Packers defense is pretty good so it's not gonna be an easy opponent to score points on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RamBall
The formation you posted with QB under center is more "wishbone" . Stafford was in shotgun with the RB split to each side. I don't like the formation with QB under Center because I think it wastes a roster spot. Our RBs can already take an odd or Even pitch lined up in I formation. However, with the QB in shotgun in this formation, I think it hurts inside gap runs because our RBs do better when they hit the hole with a longer running start. Kyren needs that extra split second for his elite vision to kick in. X Smith's Touchdown was out of this formation. It was a nice wrinkle. It gets our best playmakers on the field at the same time. And it is amazing for dink and dunk passing.

I like it sprinkled in. Other team has to respect quick pitch and screen passing game.
I say soften the Defense up with this formation if it continues to move the chains. Then throw the I formation back in for ground and pound with 11 and 13 personnel.

Our Rushing attack is most likely going to be successful in I formation.
 
I thought it was pretty effective because of Kyren's ability to run routes out of the backfield. Of course, he dropped one early, but it is something I imagine we see again. We went away from it because we started running the ball well out of 13 personnel.
 
It's a tool. It has uses. If McVay can find a way to optimize it, great!

The Packers used it quite effectively against Brandon Staley's light box defense. The Rams, last week against the Cards? Not so big of a deal. I think John Robinson used it to run the veer option a couple of times.. Martz talked about it using it but never did anything with it.

I think for this Rams team, it's a weaker run formation, as, ideally, you'd like one of the backs to be a lead blocker and I don't know if I've seen either guy do much of that. Also, ideally, I think you'd like both guys to be assets in the pass game, and I'm not so sure of Blake in the pass game, so the formation is weaker in the pass game. Wow, ok, all around, I guess, IMO, it's not optimally for the current exhibited talents of the two backs.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Alaskan Ram
I think that we should always be open to experimenting with different formations like this one so that way if something isn't really working against a certain opponent, the Rams can pivot. Got to see if this works against better defenses since this was Arizona Cardinals and their defense is generally ass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BonifayRam
The formation you posted with QB under center is more "wishbone" . Stafford was in shotgun with the RB split to each side. I don't like the formation with QB under Center because I think it wastes a roster spot. Our RBs can already take an odd or Even pitch lined up in I formation. However, with the QB in shotgun in this formation, I think it hurts inside gap runs because our RBs do better when they hit the hole with a longer running start. Kyren needs that extra split second for his elite vision to kick in. X Smith's Touchdown was out of this formation. It was a nice wrinkle. It gets our best playmakers on the field at the same time. And it is amazing for dink and dunk passing.

I like it sprinkled in. Other team has to respect quick pitch and screen passing game.
I say soften the Defense up with this formation if it continues to move the chains. Then throw the I formation back in for ground and pound with 11 and 13 personnel.

Our Rushing attack is most likely going to be successful in I formation.
I forgot I formation was 2 running backs -- one fullback in front of half back. I meant "one back" or pistol.
 
The formation you posted with QB under center is more "wishbone" . Stafford was in shotgun with the RB split to each side. I don't like the formation with QB under Center because I think it wastes a roster spot. Our RBs can already take an odd or Even pitch lined up in I formation. However, with the QB in shotgun in this formation, I think it hurts inside gap runs because our RBs do better when they hit the hole with a longer running start. Kyren needs that extra split second for his elite vision to kick in. X Smith's Touchdown was out of this formation. It was a nice wrinkle. It gets our best playmakers on the field at the same time. And it is amazing for dink and dunk passing.

I like it sprinkled in. Other team has to respect quick pitch and screen passing game.
I say soften the Defense up with this formation if it continues to move the chains. Then throw the I formation back in for ground and pound with 11 and 13 personnel.

Our Rushing attack is most likely going to be successful in I formation.
Well...of course Stafford was in shotgun...but going under center would just be a variation...but McVay can explore that also. I can remember back in the 70's the Cowboys would use it and Roger Staubach would back up into shotgun from it. A lot of board members would recall that.
 
Play with the tools you have. We currently have 2-4 banged up TEs (Higs, Park, Davis, Ferg) and speedy WRs in Tutu and Smith. I would love to see us run about 10 plays with WingT in 21 formation (2RBs and one TE).

Set a WR in motion across the formation with the option to hand off. We used this more frequently in our jet sweep 11 formation plays about 5 years ago. This would keep the defense from stacking the box and threaten the edge. This is what a spread offense essentially does and can be phased in over this week’s practice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JonRam99
I did a breakdown in another thread of all of the plays out of 20 personnel. It was effective. We ran all pass plays except for 1 run (2 yards). We will have to be able to run out of that set for it to be effective long term. Once Limmer moved to center and Murray came in at LG, the run game caught fire and they never went back to the 2 back sets.

Here are the 20 personnel plays:
1st drive:
Pass to Williams for 7 yards
Drop by Williams
Pass to Corum for 9 Yards
Pass to Atwell for 31 Yards

2nd drive:
Pass to Corum for 1 yard
Pass to Daniels for 23 yards
Handoff to Corum for 2 yards
Pass to Williams for 2 yards
Pass to Corum for 9 yards
SHELTON HURT
Interception

3rd drive
Pass to Smith for 18
Incomplete to Corum
Sack
Sack (Illegal Contact for 1st down)
Limmer to C and Murray to G
 
The Ram offense featured the split HB formation against the Cards and early in the game it worked pretty well. However the seemed to abandon it later in the 2nd quarter. I liked the formation and after a few passes to KW and Corum The Cards seemed to get a handle on it.

I think with more development, this is a good formation (typically called "pro set offense") they can do a bit more from it, though I'm not sure where McVay will go with it. I think they only had a few plays with it but in the "Pre-game thread" a few of us had talked about splitting the backs in the backfield and low and behold, we saw it .

How did you feel about the formation...should they continue to work from it or not???

A typical pro set formation:

View attachment 77852
I watched the game through NFL Redzone. Who filled the Flanker position most in this formation?
 
The Rams used it to identify coverage and occupy defenders having to cover the RBs on motion and short routes.


The RBs coverage opened up the sideline WR routes for explosives in this package.

This alignment helped Stafford identify coverage and helped the WR to get open. Im sure will see the 20P again McVay can add a few wrinkles.
 
The Rams used it to identify coverage and occupy defenders having to cover the RBs on motion and short routes.


The RBs coverage opened up the sideline WR routes for explosives in this package.

This alignment helped Stafford identify coverage and helped the WR to get open. Im sure will see the 20P again McVay can add a few wrinkles.
That's why I'm a fan of having multiple formations of how to expose a defense. With McVay's brain, if he can find ways to confuse teams by being multiple, we'd make this offense even more explosive. Also finding a way to tie each formation to each other of how they want to attack certain personel or players or parts of the field is key. For example those seam areas would be easier to get say a Ferguson out of the back field open there when running 20 personel and if the bite down on that, it can open the deep middle more.
 
For example those seam areas would be easier to get say a Ferguson out of the back field open there when running 20 personel and if the bite down on that, it can open the deep middle

I'm a little confused. Are you putting Ferguson in the backfield replacing one of th running backs? They have put him in motion to get him up the seam.
 
I'm a little confused. Are you putting Ferguson in the backfield replacing one of th running backs? They have put him in motion to get him up the seam.
Sure why not? Could also warrant attention to bring up a backer so a WR can get behind them too. There's always multiple ways to do it. Really don't understand why its a confusing concept because this formation usually doesn't have a TE in it but could. Ferg would be a bigger receiving threat than any RB and put more pressure on a defense.
 
The Ram offense featured the split HB formation against the Cards and early in the game it worked pretty well. However the seemed to abandon it later in the 2nd quarter. I liked the formation and after a few passes to KW and Corum The Cards seemed to get a handle on it.

I think with more development, this is a good formation (typically called "pro set offense") they can do a bit more from it, though I'm not sure where McVay will go with it. I think they only had a few plays with it but in the "Pre-game thread" a few of us had talked about splitting the backs in the backfield and low and behold, we saw it .

How did you feel about the formation...should they continue to work from it or not???

A typical pro set formation:

View attachment 77852
Yeah I suggested this a few weeks ago just because I felt getting better players on the field could benefit the offense.

You said it, the key is developing it a bit more. I doubt the team had much time to practice it.