Will a test for Brain Trauma protect NFL players? Or end the NFL?

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

bnw

Pro Bowler
Joined
Jan 30, 2017
Messages
1,073
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/feat...ain-trauma-protect-nfl-players-or-end-the-nfl


"During this year’s playoffs, the NFL has been airing TV commercials with the tag line “The Future of Football.” One of them shows a white-coated technician loading blood samples into a Quanterix machine. “We’re trying to develop the best tools, ones that will allow us to diagnose concussions in real time,” says the narrator, Teena Shetty, a neurologist who consults with the New York Giants. Quanterix’s concussion research fits into the NFL’s vision of a future in which head trauma is neatly contained. A pinprick sideline test would make everyone rest easy when a player who just took a head shot returns to the field.

The CTE research is less comfortable for the league. For several years after Webster died, the NFL downplayed the problem of head trauma. In 2009, after being called to testify before Congress, Goodell ducked questions about the link between football and neurological disease. “Medical experts would know better than I do,” he said.

Nobody knows how common CTE is among current and former NFL players. “Some people have said up to 90 percent,” Bailes says. “I think it’s much less than that.” Not everybody who suffers repetitive head trauma winds up with the disease. And nobody knows why some get it and others don’t. It could have to do with the intervals between hits, with genetics, with nutrition. A test for the living would make it possible to begin sorting this out, to devise prevention programs, and maybe even find drugs that can reverse the damage. This is the hope, both for CTE sufferers and for the NFL."
 

fearsomefour

Legend
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
17,154
Probably neither.
What will the standard for the test be?
What are the standards and parameters for damage?
Really hard to frame anything like that because long term damage, which is the concern, is unknown in any sort of diagnosable terms.
Will there be a standard measurement/result that correlates with long term issues? One that stands up to lawsuits?
Doubtful at this point. We are not at that point with concussions or boxers etc now.
The NFL, with billions of dollars on the line, will have a say in the framing of the testing and the rules around it.
Also, there is a right to work issue as well.
Deep sea fisherman have a tremendously dangerous job and they have a right to risk life and limb to make a living. The same, it would reason, would apply here.
So, not super optimistic about there being a huge impact in terms of protecting players.
 
Last edited: