- Joined
- Aug 12, 2012
- Messages
- 1,339
Despite some of the negative comments the poll posted in the thread shows that fans wanting to keep him outnumber fans wanting him gone 73.2 percent to 26.8 percent. He must be doing something right.
http://es.redskins.com/topic/409531-do-you-want-mcvay-back-in-2017/
Renegade7[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
It wouldn't shock me if someone offered him a HC gig, and you know what, they can have him. I'm not 100% pissed at the guy, but I do believe he just loves the pass too much to grow out of it. I'd like to keep the same system in place, but it doesn't seem like Jay is able to reel him in and coach to his talent, especially in the redzone, still forcing stuff. Someone even pointed out Trent being upset how they don't run to the left enough. I don't know about all that, but I wouldn't fight to keep McVay here. Not if we're bringing Kirk back.
Warhead36[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
McVay has positives and negatives. I think he's a good designer of offense, at least passing plays, and we generally are able to move the ball.
But man his run game design is awful. Why do we always go jumbo 3 TEs and/or Nscitzhke as 6th lineman on run plays? Or the shotgun draws? Why can't we ever just do a normal under center 2-3 WR hand off?
I also don't think he utilizes the middle of the field enough, especially the seam routes. Reed should be a terror on those but its mostly just sideline stuff or something short to Reed and hope he makes three guys miss(he often can). And the redzone playcalling is atrocious.
I'm fine with McVay staying, but if some idiot team wants him to be their HC I laugh and drive him to Dulles myself.
Burgold[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
I think McVay is fine and I'm okay with him continuing to grow and get better with us. I'd be shocked if someone offered him a HC position.
Bacon[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
No. I think a completely average football mind could get our offensive talent to produce. McVay calls the offense like he's playing Madden. Jump ball to DJax from the 1! 40 yard pass attempt on 3rd and 1! And when he does run, the designs are completely unimaginative, telegraphed or outright illogical. Chris Thompson up the gut in a jumbo package, yeah!
Taylor703[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
No. His playcalling is a joke. He doesn't understand the situation and gets cute far too often.
GregW8705[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
No. His playcalling in the red zone is atrocious. His playcalling on third down is atrocious. His playcalling in big games is atrocious. He is atrocious.
Black Market Bully[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
A good offensive coordinator makes his money in the red zone.
McVay is too busy proving how "smart" he is to the rest of the league.
Get him out of here
LetThePointsSoar[/paste:font]
Posted January 1
He's the one coordinator that I think has done enough he deserves the opportunity to keep getting better and improving his weaknesses (red zone, inconsistent play calling). On the other side of the ball, however....but I digress.
Posted January 2
yes, he needs to get the red zone woes fixed but aside from that he did a good job for year 2. dude is super young, did enough to warrant another year.
Taco Bell[/paste:font]
Posted January 3 (edited)
Honestly, even more than Barry, I want Boy Wonder gone. I navigated this season without posting much, mostly because the Cousins narrative this year wasn't as interesting as previous years top stories, but if I would have been part of that conversation, my incessant input would have been this... Cousins actually does worry me now a bit the way his arm strength and decision making looked down the stretch this year, but his positives are still enough where I'm fine with the tag or long term deal at whatever price, whatever. But, our redzone issues in particular, I would say were 80-20 Boy Wonder's fault. Doing the 1 WR do or die passes over and over and other dumb stupidity was on him, and not on Cousins. We don't have Julio Jones to throw to on those, we were throwing to Desean or Crowder or whoever. Some of that I think is him lacking the aggression and killer instinct as an OC and him possibly trying to appease personnel (cough Desean cough) and other dumb back scratching. And not sure why, but we never really seem to just blatantly attack matchup issues against other team's defenses, while it's literally commonplace for other teams to just do it because, why not, on a per play basis, who cares if you are letting the whole world see that a team's 2nd CB is garbage and worth abusing. He's too nice or something. Or too young. That's the whole thing with him. I don't feel like giving excuses to a guy just because he's new or young. I'll gladly take a 50 year old pizza eating cigar smoking NFL lifer over Boy Wonder and dealing with The Wonder Years of him trying to "figure it out."
-----------------
I just saw the reference to Trent saying he wishes they would have ran left more... exactly, that type of thing. It's almost like he didn't do it on purpose, as if, it's a crutch to rely on matchups... That's the whole purpose of the NFL.
ExoDus84[/paste:font]
Posted January 3
Some curious play calling aside, he's done an excellent job. We had one of the best offenses in football. We did struggle in the RZ this year, but our offense sure as hell was not the problem most of this year. We played a first place schedule and a hell of a lot of good to great defenses this year, yet we still produced. I'd like to see some more continuity here, as he's been a big reason for Kirk's development.
rdskn4eva[/paste:font]
Posted 9 minutes ago
Man the Redskins front office is so effing dumb
We've already lost the best offensive coordinator in the NFL (Shanahan)
Now we are about to lose the best young coordinator with McVay
Kirk will leave to follow McVay where he will have a stud running back and 0 expectations in a weak ass division
And the Redskins will have to start from scratch because Jackson and possibly Garcon will leave if Kirk isnt here so we will need to rebuild the Defense AND the offense.
I hope I'm wrong but this is what it looks like
Thanks GSM
Wyvern[/paste:font]
Posted yesterday at 07:19 AM (edited)
I think the Skins will be lucky to hang onto McVay for two years.
If the Skins can develop a decent running-back group, and improve the trouble spots with the O-line run-blocking (Lauvao mainly) -- the Skins could have another powerful offensive attack. That would draw even more attention to McVay, for the inevitable HC openings in 2018 -- and he'd probably get an offer.
I hope we can hang onto McVay this upcoming season, and I hope that Gruden is already considering who to groom as McVay's successor. (I'm still wondering about how well Callahan would be as an offensive coordinator/play caller -- he's good, but seems to be more 'old school'. And with the Skins complicated play calling structure, it's been hard to determine how well Callahan might do for the Skins offense needing to compete vs. defenses designed to play under the NFL-2018 rules.)
Garcon More Wine[/paste:font]
Posted yesterday at 08:20 AM
my biggest question would be who is more responsible for our offensive system, jay or sean. i like mcvay a lot and its clear the NFL respects his talent especially if hes getting HC interviews at age 30, but i want continuity. if we are running jay's offense and mcvay is just calling plays for it, then im not as concerned. if this is a specific scheme that mcvay is in control of, id try harder to keep him here.
our offense works, last thing i want to see is lose continuity there.
wilco_holland[/paste:font]
Posted 18 hours ago (edited)
You known what scares me.
This guy is 30 and impressed Cooley when he was his positioncoach at age of 24 or something. He is now doing great interviews. There is something special about him.
Let's say he gets the Rams job and becomes a great HC. This guy can then coach for 30 years easy!!! Thats just walking out our door.
Warhead36[/paste:font]
Posted 13 hours ago
Coaching in LA is a different animal. That situation will eat McVay up. I don't think he's ready to be a Head Coach yet and will be an absolute disaster.
But hey, let them deal with it. I'd like to see what a more experienced veteran OC can do with this talent. I think McVay got too cute sometimes and didn't really exploit the middle of the field enough.
onedrop[/paste:font]
Posted 13 hours ago
13 hours ago, Warhead36 said:
I think McVay got too cute sometimes and didn't really exploit the middle of the field enough.
I never understood that either, especially when everyone and their mom was abusing us that way. Meanwhile he ran what amounted to a 3 yard out route that took a 20 yard pass at the flatest of angles to complete like his life depended on it.
rdskn4eva[/paste:font]
Posted January 4
Excellent pass game coordinator
Running shotgun on 3rd and 2 is pissing me of tho
justice98[/paste:font]
Posted January 5
I'm fine with McVay, and feel he's an asset. Just stop calling stupid plays in the redzone.
Peregrine[/paste:font]
Posted Thursday at 02:55 PM
#3 in yards and you want to get rid of him. Oy. People dont know a good thing when they see it.
Plus, hes young, so hes making mistakes, which means he can learn, and get even better. Yes, hes messed up a few games, but, thats because he is inexperienced. Seriously, some of you dont deserve nice things.
abdcskins[/paste:font]
Posted Thursday at 03:00 PM
Our offense was the best it has been in over a decade (2012 being the exception). Keep the guy. I think once we add a quality RB things will be even better. Kelley is serviceable but we could do much better.
abdcskins[/paste:font]
Posted Thursday at 03:00 PM
Our offense was the best it has been in over a decade (2012 being the exception). Keep the guy. I think once we add a quality RB things will be even better. Kelley is serviceable but we could do much better.
http://es.redskins.com/topic/409531-do-you-want-mcvay-back-in-2017/
Renegade7[/paste:font]
- The Franchise Player
- Members
- 8,867 posts
Posted January 1
It wouldn't shock me if someone offered him a HC gig, and you know what, they can have him. I'm not 100% pissed at the guy, but I do believe he just loves the pass too much to grow out of it. I'd like to keep the same system in place, but it doesn't seem like Jay is able to reel him in and coach to his talent, especially in the redzone, still forcing stuff. Someone even pointed out Trent being upset how they don't run to the left enough. I don't know about all that, but I wouldn't fight to keep McVay here. Not if we're bringing Kirk back.
Warhead36[/paste:font]
- Ring of Fame
- Members
- 25,249 posts
Posted January 1
McVay has positives and negatives. I think he's a good designer of offense, at least passing plays, and we generally are able to move the ball.
But man his run game design is awful. Why do we always go jumbo 3 TEs and/or Nscitzhke as 6th lineman on run plays? Or the shotgun draws? Why can't we ever just do a normal under center 2-3 WR hand off?
I also don't think he utilizes the middle of the field enough, especially the seam routes. Reed should be a terror on those but its mostly just sideline stuff or something short to Reed and hope he makes three guys miss(he often can). And the redzone playcalling is atrocious.
I'm fine with McVay staying, but if some idiot team wants him to be their HC I laugh and drive him to Dulles myself.
Burgold[/paste:font]
- Ring of Fame
- Members
- 14,770 posts
Posted January 1
I think McVay is fine and I'm okay with him continuing to grow and get better with us. I'd be shocked if someone offered him a HC position.
Bacon[/paste:font]
- The Bruiser
- Members
- 9,289 posts
Posted January 1
No. I think a completely average football mind could get our offensive talent to produce. McVay calls the offense like he's playing Madden. Jump ball to DJax from the 1! 40 yard pass attempt on 3rd and 1! And when he does run, the designs are completely unimaginative, telegraphed or outright illogical. Chris Thompson up the gut in a jumbo package, yeah!
Taylor703[/paste:font]
- The Field Goal Team
- Members
- 7,644 posts
Posted January 1
No. His playcalling is a joke. He doesn't understand the situation and gets cute far too often.
GregW8705[/paste:font]
- The Camp Fodder
- Members
- 144 posts
Posted January 1
No. His playcalling in the red zone is atrocious. His playcalling on third down is atrocious. His playcalling in big games is atrocious. He is atrocious.
Black Market Bully[/paste:font]
- The Cheerleader
- Members
- 13 posts
Posted January 1
A good offensive coordinator makes his money in the red zone.
McVay is too busy proving how "smart" he is to the rest of the league.
Get him out of here
LetThePointsSoar[/paste:font]
- The Backup
- Members
- 2,534 posts
Posted January 1
He's the one coordinator that I think has done enough he deserves the opportunity to keep getting better and improving his weaknesses (red zone, inconsistent play calling). On the other side of the ball, however....but I digress.
Posted January 2
yes, he needs to get the red zone woes fixed but aside from that he did a good job for year 2. dude is super young, did enough to warrant another year.
Taco Bell[/paste:font]
- The Benchwarmer
- Members
- 897 posts
Posted January 3 (edited)
Honestly, even more than Barry, I want Boy Wonder gone. I navigated this season without posting much, mostly because the Cousins narrative this year wasn't as interesting as previous years top stories, but if I would have been part of that conversation, my incessant input would have been this... Cousins actually does worry me now a bit the way his arm strength and decision making looked down the stretch this year, but his positives are still enough where I'm fine with the tag or long term deal at whatever price, whatever. But, our redzone issues in particular, I would say were 80-20 Boy Wonder's fault. Doing the 1 WR do or die passes over and over and other dumb stupidity was on him, and not on Cousins. We don't have Julio Jones to throw to on those, we were throwing to Desean or Crowder or whoever. Some of that I think is him lacking the aggression and killer instinct as an OC and him possibly trying to appease personnel (cough Desean cough) and other dumb back scratching. And not sure why, but we never really seem to just blatantly attack matchup issues against other team's defenses, while it's literally commonplace for other teams to just do it because, why not, on a per play basis, who cares if you are letting the whole world see that a team's 2nd CB is garbage and worth abusing. He's too nice or something. Or too young. That's the whole thing with him. I don't feel like giving excuses to a guy just because he's new or young. I'll gladly take a 50 year old pizza eating cigar smoking NFL lifer over Boy Wonder and dealing with The Wonder Years of him trying to "figure it out."
-----------------
I just saw the reference to Trent saying he wishes they would have ran left more... exactly, that type of thing. It's almost like he didn't do it on purpose, as if, it's a crutch to rely on matchups... That's the whole purpose of the NFL.
ExoDus84[/paste:font]
- The Dirtbags
- Members
- 3,265 posts
Posted January 3
Some curious play calling aside, he's done an excellent job. We had one of the best offenses in football. We did struggle in the RZ this year, but our offense sure as hell was not the problem most of this year. We played a first place schedule and a hell of a lot of good to great defenses this year, yet we still produced. I'd like to see some more continuity here, as he's been a big reason for Kirk's development.
rdskn4eva[/paste:font]
- The Role Player
- Members
- 1,366 posts
Posted 9 minutes ago
Man the Redskins front office is so effing dumb
We've already lost the best offensive coordinator in the NFL (Shanahan)
Now we are about to lose the best young coordinator with McVay
Kirk will leave to follow McVay where he will have a stud running back and 0 expectations in a weak ass division
And the Redskins will have to start from scratch because Jackson and possibly Garcon will leave if Kirk isnt here so we will need to rebuild the Defense AND the offense.
I hope I'm wrong but this is what it looks like
Thanks GSM
Wyvern[/paste:font]
- The Backup
- Members
- 2,995 posts
Posted yesterday at 07:19 AM (edited)
I think the Skins will be lucky to hang onto McVay for two years.
If the Skins can develop a decent running-back group, and improve the trouble spots with the O-line run-blocking (Lauvao mainly) -- the Skins could have another powerful offensive attack. That would draw even more attention to McVay, for the inevitable HC openings in 2018 -- and he'd probably get an offer.
I hope we can hang onto McVay this upcoming season, and I hope that Gruden is already considering who to groom as McVay's successor. (I'm still wondering about how well Callahan would be as an offensive coordinator/play caller -- he's good, but seems to be more 'old school'. And with the Skins complicated play calling structure, it's been hard to determine how well Callahan might do for the Skins offense needing to compete vs. defenses designed to play under the NFL-2018 rules.)
Garcon More Wine[/paste:font]
- The Special Teams Ace
- Members
- 352 posts
Posted yesterday at 08:20 AM
my biggest question would be who is more responsible for our offensive system, jay or sean. i like mcvay a lot and its clear the NFL respects his talent especially if hes getting HC interviews at age 30, but i want continuity. if we are running jay's offense and mcvay is just calling plays for it, then im not as concerned. if this is a specific scheme that mcvay is in control of, id try harder to keep him here.
our offense works, last thing i want to see is lose continuity there.
wilco_holland[/paste:font]
- The Dutch Rub
- Members
- 3,983 posts
Posted 18 hours ago (edited)
You known what scares me.
This guy is 30 and impressed Cooley when he was his positioncoach at age of 24 or something. He is now doing great interviews. There is something special about him.
Let's say he gets the Rams job and becomes a great HC. This guy can then coach for 30 years easy!!! Thats just walking out our door.
Warhead36[/paste:font]
- Ring of Fame
- Members
- 25,249 posts
Posted 13 hours ago
Coaching in LA is a different animal. That situation will eat McVay up. I don't think he's ready to be a Head Coach yet and will be an absolute disaster.
But hey, let them deal with it. I'd like to see what a more experienced veteran OC can do with this talent. I think McVay got too cute sometimes and didn't really exploit the middle of the field enough.
onedrop[/paste:font]
- The Deep Threat
- Members
- 4,211 posts
Posted 13 hours ago
13 hours ago, Warhead36 said:
I think McVay got too cute sometimes and didn't really exploit the middle of the field enough.
I never understood that either, especially when everyone and their mom was abusing us that way. Meanwhile he ran what amounted to a 3 yard out route that took a 20 yard pass at the flatest of angles to complete like his life depended on it.
rdskn4eva[/paste:font]
- The Role Player
- Members
- 1,366 posts
Posted January 4
Excellent pass game coordinator
Running shotgun on 3rd and 2 is pissing me of tho
justice98[/paste:font]
- The Gadget Play
- Members
- 7,772 posts
Posted January 5
I'm fine with McVay, and feel he's an asset. Just stop calling stupid plays in the redzone.
Peregrine[/paste:font]
- Watergirl
- Members
- 7,474 posts
Posted Thursday at 02:55 PM
#3 in yards and you want to get rid of him. Oy. People dont know a good thing when they see it.
Plus, hes young, so hes making mistakes, which means he can learn, and get even better. Yes, hes messed up a few games, but, thats because he is inexperienced. Seriously, some of you dont deserve nice things.
abdcskins[/paste:font]
- The Dirtbags
- Members
- 3,898 posts
Posted Thursday at 03:00 PM
Our offense was the best it has been in over a decade (2012 being the exception). Keep the guy. I think once we add a quality RB things will be even better. Kelley is serviceable but we could do much better.
abdcskins[/paste:font]
- The Dirtbags
- Members
- 3,898 posts
Posted Thursday at 03:00 PM
Our offense was the best it has been in over a decade (2012 being the exception). Keep the guy. I think once we add a quality RB things will be even better. Kelley is serviceable but we could do much better.
