Jeff Fisher in Consideration
By: Joey Bittick
On Twitter: @joeybittick
![]()
Well, the times, they are changing… Steve Spagnuolo and Billy Devaney are out at Rams Park. I would like to thank them for their service to the Rams. They may not have managed to have a great amount of success, but I appreciate the long hours they gave to my team. They seemed to me like truly nice men and I wish them the best. With that said, it is time to look forward. And it appears the Rams may have a big fish on the line.
Former Tennessee Titans head coach Jeff Fisher has been rumored to be the front runner for the recently vacated Rams head coaching job. I have to admit, when his name first popped up as a possible candidate I was not all that fired up about it. Fisher never seemed to have what I would call “sustained success” with the Titans. His teams always seemed to be up and down. One year his team would go 13-3 and the next year they would fall of the face of the NFL world. And there were also those early playoff exits… but now, the more I look into the guy, the more I think he may just be the man to lead the Rams back to prominence.
The reasons to consider hiring Jeff Fisher:
- Experience: To borrow a cliché, Fisher is a football lifer. He was an All-American wide receiver in high school, a star at USC, and he was a member of the 1985 Bears defense that led them to a Super Bowl. He ended the 1985 season on IR, but was not content to sit and stay and watch his team go on without him, instead becoming a defensive assistant to Buddy Ryan. He later became the youngest defensive coordinator in the NFL when he took the position with the Eagles in 1988. In 1994 Fisher was named the head coach of the then Houston Oilers with six games remaining in the season, and he would continue on in that role for the next 16 plus seasons.
- Pedigree: It may not seem overly important, but I believe that Fisher’s pedigree is a huge plus. He served as an assistant under guys like Mike Ditka (.560 winning percentage and went 106-62 with a Super Bowl in 11 years with the Bears), George Seifert (.648 winning percentage in his career and two Super Bowl trophies with the 49ers), John Robinson (6 playoff appearances in 9 years with the LA Rams), Buddy Ryan (famed architect of the famous Bears defenses), and Jack Pardee (made playoffs in his first 4 seasons with the Houston Oilers). Obviously Fisher learned from some of the best, and that can never hurt.
- Teacher: Several Fisher disciples have gone on to be head coaches including Gregg Williams, Jim Schwartz, and Mike Munchak. Williams may not have had much success as a head guy, but his defense helped the Saints win a Superbowl. Obviously Fisher knows how to teach guys what it takes to have success in the NFL.
- Strong Supporting Staff: This ties into number three, but many have taken to criticizing Spags for putting together a “weak” coaching staff. Regardless of whether this is true, Fisher obviously has put together some strong staffs, which in turn should equal well coached players.
- Rams Ties: A small thing, but given the previous regime’s propensity for ignoring the Rams previous success and history, it may please some fans that Fisher should (hopefully) embrace it. He served as an assistant to John Robinson for the LA Rams, so he should at least have some appreciation for those that came before him.
- “The Magic Touch”: The guy took Kerry Collins off of the scrap heap and turned him back into a viable starting QB for a 13-3 playoff team. Did Collins set any records? No, but he still was able to manage them to a number one seed in the playoffs via a formidable ground game.
- Motivator: This one is real simple… the guy helped make ALBERT HAYNESWORTH the best defensive player in the game. We all saw what happened to him upon leaving Tennessee.
- Competitive Teams: It has become cliché to say this but at least Spags’ teams always went out and competed their hardest. The same can be said for Fisher’s teams. The difference? This competitive attitude translated into…
- Wins: That is what it all comes down to in the NFL, and Fisher has shown he knows how to do that. 7-9 was the high water mark for Spags and Devaney, while Fisher’s teams were 7-9 or better in 13 of his 16 full seasons as Oilers/Titans head coach.
The Reason’s to be wary of hiring Jeff Fisher:
- Inconsistency: Despite his longevity, Fisher only had 6 winning season in 16 full seasons as head coach. His record in those non-winning seasons? 69-91. Not overly impressive, but consider this. That is an average of just under 7 wins during those seasons. In fact, he only had 3 season of less than 7 wins (winning 6,5, and then 4 games in those seasons). 7 wins per down year sounds pretty good to most Rams fans right now.
- Playoff Struggles: If there is one area where Fisher has come up woefully short as a head coach, it is in the playoffs. I am not one who puts all of the blame or praise on a head coach. In fact, I would say that most of the time, the head coach deserves at most, 10-15% of the credit whether the team wins or loses. However, I can see why people might look at his 5-6 record in the playoffs and wonder if the guy is really as good a head coach as most perceive him to be. Then, when you consider that his teams were one and done in 3 of their 6 playoff appearances (including twice when they were a number one seed) well, it certainly gives reason for pause.
- “Mike Shanahan Syndrome”?: I am not sure what else to call it, but everyone thought Mike Shanahan was a genius when he was coaching guys like Terrell Davis and (more importantly) John Elway. When he was coaching Brian Griese and Olandis Gary? Not so much. Well, the same could possibly be said for Fisher. When he had guys like Steve McNair and Eddie George playing for him he was a genius. When Vince Young was forced upon him?
This is by no means a comprehensive list of the pro’s and con’s that come with hiring Jeff Fisher as the Rams head coach, but these things are certain to be considered by the powers that be at Rams Park. As one can see, Jeff Fisher’s resume is certainly less than pristine. He comes with some risk. But so did Dick Vermeil…












